Cat Scratching Post vs. Scratching Pad: Which Does Your Cat Really Need?

You've bought the scratcher. Your cat has ignored it and chosen the sofa instead. Sound familiar? The problem is usually a mismatch: cats scratch in different ways, and the scratcher has to match the style. Here's how to tell whether your cat needs a post or a pad — and how to make either one irresistible.

Why Cats Scratch

Scratching isn't spite — it's a biological need. Cats scratch to mark territory (they have scent glands in their paws), stretch and strengthen their back and shoulder muscles, maintain their claws by peeling off dull outer sheaths, and relieve stress. If you remove the ability to scratch without providing an alternative, you'll get shredded curtains. Our guide on how cats show affection explains why claw-marking is actually a compliment of sorts.

Post vs. Pad: Match the Style

Vertical scratching (posts): Cats that scratch doorframes, chair backs, and sofa arms are vertical scratchers — they like to stretch tall while digging in. A tall, sturdy post (at least 3 feet, with a sisal surface) that lets them stretch to full length is the match. Anchor it well — a wobbly post is a dealbreaker.

Horizontal scratching (pads): Cats that scratch rugs, carpet, and mattress corners are horizontal scratchers. A flat cardboard or sisal pad on the floor suits them perfectly. Place pads near where they already scratch — you're giving them a legal version of their favorite spot.

Most cats want both. The ideal home has one of each, placed in high-traffic areas where your cat actually spends time — not tucked in a corner. And always near the litter box area? Not necessarily — scratching posts near sleeping and entry points get the most use.

How to Make the Switch Stick

• Rub catnip on the new scratcher to make it instantly attractive.
• Play near it — dangle a toy so claws hit the post during play.
• Never punish scratching; redirect instead.
• Cover the old target temporarily with double-sided tape or foil while the new scratcher becomes the habit.

Multi-cat households need multiple scratchers in different styles — check our guide to introducing a second cat for territory management tips, and watch the Jackson Galaxy Cat Corner for expert scratching advice. For a full breakdown of cat behavior, the Cat Behavior Decoder ($5.99) and Cat vs. Cat eBook ($12.99) are excellent next steps.